Tuttle-Fordham Mill - Speonk

 In 1985, the Tuttle-Fordham Mill, located in Speonk was designated as the first Town of Southampton historic Landmark. The original wooden sawmill no longer present, which milled lumber of many of our community’s early homes, was constructed by members of the Jagger family in the early 1800s. The sawmill was powered by a pond created by damming the upper reach of the Speonk River.

The Fordham Mill was built by Daniel Wells Tuttle in 1859. A dam on the Speonk River powered the sawmill, which the Tuttle family ran until it was purchased by E.O. Fordham in 1911 and converted to electric power. Mr. Fordham made carriages, wagon wheels and coffins. The Tuttles leased the Mill to Everett O. Fordham in 1895; Mr. Fordham bought the Mill in 1911 and transformed it to electric power. Fordham’s long-time employee, Wilbur Benjamin, bought the Mill in 1946 and continued operations until he sold the property in 1959. Sawmill operations were continued onsite by the Moriches Woodworking Co., Inc., owned by John Salomon until about 1975. 

Unoccupied for some time, the Mill descended into a state of significant disrepair and its foundation became seriously compromised. In March 2017, the John and Elaine Kanas Family Foundation purchased the property that includes the 1859 Tuttle-Fordham Mill, assuming full responsibility for its preservation and appropriate reuse. The Foundation undertook the significant repairs needed, coordinating this work with the Town’s Landmarks & Historic Districts Board as required for a landmarked property.

Thanks to John and Elaine Kanas and their Foundation, the Tuttle-Fordham Mill has been restored.

Sources:

Gorman, Alexa. “Fordham Mill Added to Endangered Places Registry.” 27east, 14 Feb. 2015, www.27east.com/residence/real-estate-news/article_17826f66-f127-5ca7-b002-c66f19bb85d2.html

“Tuttle-Fordham Mill History.” Greater Westhampton Historical Museum, whbhistorical.org/tuttle-fordham-mill-history/. Accessed 7 Apr. 2026