Tuttle-Fordham Mill - Speonk

 In 1985, the Tuttle-Fordham Mill, located in Speonk was designated as the first Town of Southampton historic Landmark. The original wooden sawmill no longer present, which milled lumber of many of our community’s early homes, was constructed by members of the Jagger family in the early 1800s. The sawmill was powered by a pond created by damming the upper reach of the Speonk River.

The Fordham Mill was built by Daniel Wells Tuttle in 1859. A dam on the Speonk River powered the sawmill, which the Tuttle family ran until it was purchased by E.O. Fordham in 1911 and converted to electric power. Mr. Fordham made carriages, wagon wheels and coffins. The Tuttles leased the Mill to Everett O. Fordham in 1895; Mr. Fordham bought the Mill in 1911 and transformed it to electric power. Fordham’s long-time employee, Wilbur Benjamin, bought the Mill in 1946 and continued operations until he sold the property in 1959. Sawmill operations were continued onsite by the Moriches Woodworking Co., Inc., owned by John Salomon until about 1975. 

Unoccupied for some time, the Mill descended into a state of significant disrepair and its foundation became seriously compromised. In March 2017, the John and Elaine Kanas Family Foundation purchased the property that includes the 1859 Tuttle-Fordham Mill, assuming full responsibility for its preservation and appropriate reuse. The Foundation undertook the significant repairs needed, coordinating this work with the Town’s Landmarks & Historic Districts Board as required for a landmarked property.

Thanks to John and Elaine Kanas and their Foundation, the Tuttle-Fordham Mill has been restored.

Sources:

Gorman, Alexa. “Fordham Mill Added to Endangered Places Registry.” 27east, 14 Feb. 2015, www.27east.com/residence/real-estate-news/article_17826f66-f127-5ca7-b002-c66f19bb85d2.html

“Tuttle-Fordham Mill History.” Greater Westhampton Historical Museum, whbhistorical.org/tuttle-fordham-mill-history/. Accessed 7 Apr. 2026

Baseball Player Carlton Edwards

Carlton Edwards was born on October 23, 1929, in Stony Brook. His mother Marjorie Edwards, his grandmother and his brother moved to Chicken Hill area of Setauket soon after. He was a gifted all-around athlete, best known for his pitching. He pitched for the all-Black Setauket Giants and later for the newly integrated Setauket Athletic Club, carving out a reputation as a dependable and accomplished pitcher. In 1951, he received an offer from the Brooklyn Dodgers, a moment that hinted at how far his baseball career might go. That same year, however, his life took a different turn when he was drafted into the United States Army.

That commitment to service extended well beyond his military years in the Korean War. Edwards was deeply involved with the American Legion Irving Hart Post 1766, which was founded after World War II to serve Black and Hispanic servicemen. In order to satisfy the 15-member requirement to keep the legion in operation, Edwards would often pay for other members

Edwards had a 40-year career with the Three Village Central School District. He was very active in the Three Village Historical Society. On Sundays, he greeted visitors at the historical society, digging up lesser known details about the Chicken Hill area.

In 2023, Edwards’ lifetime of athletic and community contributions was formally recognized with his induction into the Suffolk County Sports Hall of Fame. Carlton Edwards died on January 17, 2026 at the age of 96.

Sources:

Artusa, Sabrina. “Obituary: In Remembrance of Carlton ‘Hub’ Edwards.” TBR Newsmedia, 21 Jan. 2026, tbrnewsmedia.com/obituary-in-remembrance-of-carlton-hub-edwards

Vaccaro, Chris. “Suffolk Hall of Famer Carlton ‘Hub’ Edwards, Baseball Pioneer, Dies at 96.” Suffolk Sports Hall of Fame, 23 Jan. 2026, www.suffolksportshof.com/suffolk-hall-of-famer-carlton-hub-edwards-baseball-pioneer-dies-at-96

Squire Farm - Plainview

The Squire farm was originally built by the Whitson family. A windmill for pumping water was erected in 1907 by Irving Squire. This was not the first wind machine on the property. According to an 1859 map, the Whitson family operated a grist mill there in the 1850s. It would be used as a post office and a polling place in the late 19^th Century.

The farm produced carrots, cabbages, onions, beets, potatoes, spinach, corn, cucumber and dill. The cucumber and dill were grown specifically for Karp & Fueschel pickleworks. The entire farm covered 330 acres extending along both sides of Old Country Road.

The farmhouse had seven bedrooms, two baths, a poolroom, a parlor, kitchen, and a dining room. During World War I, a teacher at Bushwick High School arranged with the farm for boys from the city would come to the farm and learn how to work it. They called them “farm camp boys.” The boys cooked and served their own meals in a separate building which they called B. H. S. Camp Squire. The boys would plow, seed the ground, and thin and weed the row for harvesting. The goods from the farm were sent overseas to the boys serving.

No trace is left of the windmill or dwelling.

 

Source:

Gibbs, Iris & Alonzo. “B. H. S. Camp Squire.” Long Island Forum. March, 1973

Harbor Hill Estate & Gate House - Roslyn

Among the largest estates on Long Island was the Renaissance –style mansion known as Harbor Hill designed in 1899 by Stanford White and built in 1900 to 1902 for Clarence H. Mackay and his wife Katherine. The 576-acre estate was located atop the highest point in the area overlooking the village of Roslyn and Hempstead Harbor.

This country home estate was divided into formal gardens and terraces surrounding the main house and a 70-acre farm. With Clarence Mackay’s death in 1938, the estate was left to his son John Mackay III. Due to vandalism during the World War II, the mansion was demolished in 1947. The property was sold in the late 1950s and became the Country Estates housing development.

The Mackay Estate Gate Lodge was built in 1900-1902 as a component of the estate. The still-standing gate lodge was designed as a miniature version of the main house. Both the main house and the gate lodge were designed in French Baroque style with stone walls and steep roof slopes. 

The Mackay Estate Gate Lodge is one of only three buildings still standing from the Mackay Harbor Hill Estate (Dairyman’s Cottage and the John Mackay III Stonehouse). On April 12, 1991, the Mackay Estate Gate Lodge was listed on the New York State and National Register of Historic Places.

From approximately 1970 to 2008, the Mackay Estate Gate Lodge was used as the Country Estates Swim Club. The Mackay Estate Gate Lodge and surrounding 3.2-acre property was sold to G.A.D. Development in 2009. With the assistance of then town historian Howard Kroplick, G.A.D Development considered transferring the gate lodge property either to the Town of North Hempstead or the Village of East Hills. On September 3, 2017, the Village of East Hills decided to acquire the Mackay Estate Gate Lodge. 

When a subdivision was approved by Nassau County, the deed to the gate lodge was transferred to the Village of East Hills in December 2021. With the guidance of the Roslyn Landmark Society, the restoration of the Mackay Estate Gate Lodge began on January 25, 2022.

Sources: 

“Harbor Hill Estate.” Roslyn Landmark Society, 1 Jan. 1967, www.roslynlandmarks.org/profiles/harbor-hill-estate. 

 “Harbor Hill Gate Lodge.” Roslyn Landmark Society, 1 Jan. 1969, www.roslynlandmarks.org/profiles/harbor-hill-gate-house. 

Carrington House - Fire island

The Carrington House is located on a tract of land between Fire island Pines and Cherry Grove. It is one of the earliest homes built on Fire Island, originally constructed in 1912 by Frederick Marquat, and purchased in 1927 by theater director Frank Carrington, co-founder of the Paper Mill playhouse. The house was built in 1909 by Frederick Marquat, a US Army Corporal that served with Carrington’s father, Major Frank Carrington.

The two families used this retreat until 1927, at which point Frank bought the property and turned the space into a nexus for the cultural development of mid-century arts. At the time, the cottage was a rectangular, three bay bungalow. Carrington made two wood-frame additions around 1940. Frank Carrington expanded the property with the “Lone Hill Cottage” built in 1948. Carrington was active in the growing arts community of Cherry Grove. He rented the property to his friends in the community, including Truman Capote. In 1957, Capote developed a novella there that would become Breakfast at Tiffany's.

At one point Frank Carrington was offered $1.5M for the property by a real estate developer but was more interested in preserving the site, so sold it to the National Park Service in 1969 for approximately $300,000 and continued living there until 1975. National Park Service Ranger Bob Freda lived there for the next twenty years. The Carrington House is probably the oldest surviving building in Cherry Grove.

 In 2016, the property was placed on the National Registry of Historic Places.

 

Sources:

“Carrington House.” Wikipedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 1 June 2025, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carrington_House

 

Hildebrandt, Bill. “The History of Fire Island’s Carrington House.” Fire Island Pines Historical Society, Fire Island Pines Historical Society, 11 Jan. 2026, www.pineshistory.org/the-archives/the-history-of-fire-islands-carrington-house

Childs Frick Estate/Nassau County Museum of Art

 In 1900, Lloyd Stephens Bryce purchased poet William Cullen Bryant’s Upland Farm and commissioned the architect Ogden Codman to design a neo-Georgian mansion on an elevated site overlooking Hempstead Harbor for he and his wife Edith. The Georgian-Revival house was laid out on Palladian lines with a three-story central block attached by two single story arcades to a pair of two-story pavilions set forward from the main house. Codman added his trademark preference - arched windows. Next to the house, Codman laid out parterre gardens and the rich lawn bordered by woodland gradually sloped down to the water.

In 1919, Henry Clay Frick, co-founder of US Steel Corporation, purchased Bryce House. He unfortunately died shortly after, so his son Childs and wife Frances Frick got possession of the house. They hired British architect Sir Charles Carrick Allom to redesign the facade as well as the interior of their new home, which they named Clayton after Childs’s childhood home. 

Childs Frick was an avid sportsman and lover of the outdoors. At Clayton, he and his family enjoyed swimming, tennis, polo, golf, and skiing on his estate, which included two tennis courts (one grass and one clay), a polo field, two ponds for skating and canoeing, a shooting range, a swimming pool, bridle paths, and a ski slope with its own snow making machine. The family’s love of animals and the outdoors included a large animal zoo with a bear pit, snakes, and an alligator, an aviary, a monkey house, and otters in a pond. 

Frances and Childs Frick lived at Clayton with their children, Adelaide, Frances, Martha and Henry for almost 50 years. Four years after Childs Frick died, the estate was purchased by Nassau County to establish the Nassau County Museum of Fine Art in 1969.

In 1989, the Museum became a private not-for-profit institution, governed and funded by its own board of trustees. A major exterior restoration of the historic mansion was undertaken and the mansion was then renamed the Arnold and Joan Saltzman Fine Arts Building.

A sculpture park was begun in 1989 and became one of the largest publicly-accessible sculpture parks in the Northeast.

Sources:

“Clayton.” American Aristocracy, americanaristocracy.com/houses/clayton-1. Accessed 5 Jan. 2026

“History.” Nassau County Museum of Art, nassaumuseum.org/history/. Accessed 5 Jan. 2026

William Sydney Mount House

American painter William Sidney Mount created some of his most memorable scenes from inside an attic studio at this large, rambling 18th century homestead. Located at the intersection of North Country Road in Stony Brook, Mount’s ancestral family home, the Hawkins-Mount House, was built around 1725, and substantially enlarged over the centuries. 

Mount, his mother, and his four siblings moved to the house in 1814. The barn and outbuildings at the back of the property also featured prominently in his genre work. Living year-round in the house by 1847, Mount had a skylight installed in the ceiling of his garret studio to improve the lighting. 

It is a 2 1/2-story wood-frame structure, with a gabled roof and shingled exterior. The main entrance is sheltered by a shed-roof porch and has a four-light transom window. The interior of the house has more than twenty rooms. The most notable of these is its original kitchen, which has been restored. The oldest part of the house is the left side of the main building. It was built in 1725 by Eleazer Hawkins. He was William Sidney Mount's grandfather. Mr. Hawkins built it as an "ordinary," which was like a tavern or inn. Travelers could stop there for food and a place to stay. The kitchen from this old tavern is still preserved today.

The house remained in family hands until just after World War I and was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1966. The house is now owned by the Long Island Museum and is occasionally opened for tours.

Sources:

“William Sidney Mount House Facts for Kids.” Kiddle, 17 Oct. 2025, kids.kiddle.co/William_Sidney_Mount_House

“William Sidney Mount House.” Historic Artists’ Sites of Long Island, www.lihistoricartistssites.org/detail/william-sidney-mount-house. Accessed 27 Dec. 2025

“William Sidney Mount House.” Wikipedia, Wikimedia Foundation, 5 July 2025, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Sidney_Mount_House